Re: Good 2m rig?

WA7SKG <wa7skg@...>
 

You are comparing apples and oranges. The "Data Port" on ham radios is a misnomer. It is a port for audio connections, just like the microphone jack. It typically has PTT, TX and RX audio (often from two locations in the radio for wide/narrow audio bandwidth), COS, and other signals. This is designed to use with some hardware interface (TNC, modem, etc.) or sound card (Signalink, etc.) device. Your USB connectors are for just that, USB connections for power and data transfer. Trying to use a mini-USB (4 pins) connector or micro-USB (5 pins) for an analog signal cable is a recipe for disaster.

When manufacturers first started interfacing with radios, they simply used the microphone connector. This often required the use of an external switch box go go between the TNC and the microphone so the radio could be used for dual purposes. Then, users wanted to hook both devices simultaneously, plus wanted added features (discriminator tap for UHF packet, COS, etc.) The mini-DIN 6 pin connector was an industry standard at the time, used for PS/2 connections to computers and other purposes. Readily available, inexpensive, smaller than Molex or DB connectors, it was a good choice and became somewhat a standard for the purpose.

So, hopefully, that may answer your "Why do so many of you want a DIN-6 port?" question.

Your other comments regarding the different HT/computer interfaces, compatibilities between adapter/OS, drivers, baud rates, etc. are a totally different issue. That is regarding purely data interfaces via USB and converted serial data. Completely irrelevant to the conversation at hand.

73,
Michael WA7SKG


Al Szymanski via Groups.Io wrote on 5/24/19 2:01 PM:

Not so much as a reply , but a genuine question.
Why do so many of you want a DIN-6 port? Technology-wise, it's almost 50 years old. It's huge. If you could , wouldn't you rather have a 2-Meter rig with a Mini-USB, Micro-USB or ( yuck ) USB-C ? Is it the throughput? Is it because "It's what all my cables are already" ?
My perspective is that it's an issue to connect any HT to a computer and have it behave nicely. 1) gotta have the right USB to whatever is offered as a data/mic/speaker port. 2) depending on the OS , you gotta have / find the drivers for this unique cable so that the computer will recognize it and 3) now that the radio and computer "CAN" talk to each other, can it communicate? Was that 9600 baud or 14400? Is there a CRC?
Our cellphones do this with nearly no effort - why can't manufacturers?
Al
K7AOZ

Join main@nw-digital-radio.groups.io to automatically receive all group messages.