Re: Open Source Hardware...

"William Stillwell - KI4SWY" <wkstill@...>

the comment “ … doesn’t exist” is in accurate.


Ardruino is very open source hardware. (all the way down to the boot loader, and development packages)


Fpga projects can be open source as well.


UDR is not open source hardware, it supports open source software development.


Unlike 99% of all “node adapters” are 100% closed software development.


Yes, no chip manufacture is going to give you there chip secrets, but they sure are going to tell you how you can use it.



From: UniversalDigitalRadio@... [mailto:UniversalDigitalRadio@...] On Behalf Of UniversalDigitalRadio-owner@...
Sent: Wednesday, May 23, 2012 3:02 PM
To: UniversalDigitalRadio@...
Subject: [UniversalDigitalRadio] Open Source Hardware...



... doesn't exist.

This forum has been wonderfully active on a variety of topics. It's great to see the exchange as hams weigh in with their hopes and dreams, but there is one topic that I need to address; the notion of open source hardware.

I worked in Silicon Valley for 30 years, both with and for, a variety of semiconductor companies. I have personally negotiated with both ARM and MIPs and let me tell you, there is no open source hardware.

Today's designs use high integration ICs which are designed in HDLs. They often include licensed IP from other sources under highly restrictive agreements. They are the companies most valuable assets and they are not released to anyone in any form.

In order for us to use these devices we may enter into Non Disclosure Agreements which state that we will not release any design information to third parties, that means you. In particular if there are errata we cannot share either the problem or the fix.

LEGAL DISCLAIMER: I am not saying that any vendors chips that I use now, or have ever used, actually have now or ever have had any errata (hi hi).

What we will provide is schematics and assembly diagrams of released product under copyright. In particular, we will document all connector interfaces both external and internal, to aid in experimentation.

We will not be posting manufacturing data, such as gerber files, detailed BOMs and mechanical drawings, but if you have an amateur radio project that requires more information; send us an email briefly describing what you'r trying to do and we'll do our best to help you.

73 - Bryan Hoyer

Join to automatically receive all group messages.